Such fierce demands for naive belief

Such Fierce Demands for Naïve Belief  —  On Singing Holocaust Era Songs for a 21st century Audience                     

                           by Jane Enkin December 2016

Such fierce demands for naïve belief”              page 225, 9 ½ Mystics by Herbert Weiner

Such fierce

demands for naïve


are not uncommon

We make fierce demands

of our lovers

our children

our students

our audiences

Come with me now

to a ghetto cabaret in Poland in 1943

Believe that I am


and harried

And that I am

dark and exquisite

Hunger has made

my cheeks delicate branches

my eyes hidden lakes

my hands the little fish

you cannot catch

Catch these layers

Believe you must give your buzzing mind

Over to me

in stillness

Believe that we together

are in Poland, in 1943

Believe I am

that singer

in that cabaret

I am dark,

but I am lovely


Believe in the woman

the singer creates for you

Even more hungry,

more lost

Could such despair

be offered in song?


as the imagined woman’s grandmother

heard despair


in the hazzan’s penance offered in synagogue

for the community of sinners


as the grandmother

murmured in

the darkest lullabies ever set to soothing tunes


as her quiet irony

Believe in


Believe in

the singer in 1943

Believe in

the character she creates in the song

Now, one more demand


that each thought comes to me fresh

each breath

each shattering



gathering of strength

Believe that each

moment of the song


for the first time

at the moment we share it

This is the fierce

naïve belief

I demand of you,

my audience

This is the naiveté I offer



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s